What landlords can do when tenants decide not to renew leases

Every landlord and property manager strives for high renewal rates, but tenant non-renewals are an inevitable part of the business. This makes it crucial to understand how to prepare before renewal dates, approach renewal conversations effectively, and handle tenant refusals.

This guide offers best practices for managing lease renewals and strategies for dealing with tenants who decide not to renew. With the right approach, you can maintain high occupancy rates and build strong tenant relationships.

How to ask a tenant if they will renew lease

As a tenant’s lease period comes to an end, it’s your responsibility to start the renewal conversation. A lease renewal letter is the best way to ask a tenant if they plan to stay in your multifamily property. This formal notice is sent to the tenant and outlines the terms of the renewal. Here’s what you need to include in the letter:

• Date the lease renewal letter is sent
• Tenant name/s
• Property address
• The current lease expiration date
• Whether or not the lease will be renewed
• The proposed new lease term
• Any changes in rent amount or lease conditions
• A deadline for the tenant’s response
• Your contact information for any questions

You will need to send the lease renewal letter to the tenant via certified mail or email. This provides a record that the tenant was properly notified. You can also follow up with a friendly reminder if you don’t receive a response within the given timeframe.

Benefit of early discussions with tenants

You are required to provide a lease renewal notice to tenants 90 days before the lease expires. This gives tenants sufficient time to make their decision. It also ensures they can comply with the 60-day or 30-day notice of non-renewal, depending on your state regulations and tenant agreement.

Beyond regulatory compliance, starting the renewal conversation early offers advantages. If a tenant is considering not renewing, early discussions give you the opportunity to address any concerns they may have. This allows you to make necessary improvements that might encourage them to stay.

If tenants are set on leaving, early notice gives you ample time to find new tenants. This proactive approach helps you avoid extended vacancy periods and maintain steady occupancy rates.

It’s crucial to check your state laws to ensure you’re timing the conversation appropriately. In New York, for example, you cannot send the lease renewal notice more than 150 days before the lease ends.

Encouraging tenants to consider renewal

Encouraging tenants to renew their leases requires a thoughtful approach. Here are a few strategies to follow:

Make the renewal process easy

A complicated renewal process can prompt tenants to consider moving. Ensure your process is straightforward, easy to understand, and allows ample time so tenants don’t feel pressured. Be readily available to answer questions and address concerns, making renewals a stress-free experience for your tenants.

Highlight the benefits of your multifamily property

In your lease renewal letter, emphasize the unique benefits of living in your multifamily property. Mention any recent amenity upgrades, future technology installment plans, and any instances of tailored management services. Reminding tenants of the positive aspects of your property can help encourage them to renew.

Ensure considerate rent increases

When a rent increase is necessary, keep it reasonable and in line with market rates. Clearly explaining the reasons for the increase can help maintain transparency and trust. To encourage renewals when you are increasing your rent, offer small perks or upgrades that add value and show appreciation for their continued stay in your property.

Create an appealing environment for tenants

A functional, comfortable, and attractive multifamily property makes it harder for tenants to leave. There are a few ways you can do this, including:

Keep the property well-maintained

Tenants want to live in a clean and safe environment. Performing regular maintenance tasks and responding quickly to repairs will show tenants throughout their tenancy that you care about their living conditions. This enhances their satisfaction, leading to loyalty and lease renewals.

Strategic property upgrades

Upgrading amenities and technology will improve the tenant experience in your multifamily property. Consider investing in modern appliances, IoT security devices, fast internet, and updated common areas. Showing tenants that you want to provide the best living experience can make a difference in their decisions.

Create a sense of community

Your multifamily community management will play a big role in tenants deciding to stay or leave. Help your tenants feel a sense of belonging in your property by organizing social gatherings, offering communal areas for neighborly interactions, and sending community updates regularly.

Can a tenant refuse to renew a lease?

Yes, a tenant can refuse to renew a lease. They are not obligated to extend their tenancy and may choose to move out for various reasons.

Reasons for tenant not renewing lease

Often, non-renewals are driven by personal circumstances, such as relocating for a new job or needing more space for a growing family. While it’s not ideal to see tenants leave, it’s important to respect their changing needs.

Tenants may also choose to move due to property, cost, or management-related issues. They might be dissatisfied with maintenance standards, have had negative experiences with staff, or feel that the property no longer meets their expectations.

When the tenant refuses to sign lease renewal

Despite your best efforts, some tenants will choose not to renew their leases. It’s important to understand their reasons, handle these situations professionally, and prepare for the next steps.

Requesting feedback

It’s always helpful to ask for feedback to understand whether they are leaving due to personal circumstances or property-related issues. Knowing these reasons allows you to make improvements and prevent future non-renewals.

Offer solutions

When discussing non-renewal, offer solutions without pressuring the tenant. Suggest alternatives that might address their concerns, such as maintenance improvements or flexible lease terms. This shows you value their tenancy and are willing to adjust to meet their needs.

Remain professional

While a tenant deciding not to renew is not ideal, it’s crucial to remain supportive and professional. Providing excellent service during their move-out process can lead to positive word-of-mouth referrals. A positive last impression might also encourage them to reconsider their decision or return in the future.

Preparations for re-listing the property

Once a tenant confirms they won’t be renewing, start preparing the property for the next renter immediately. This includes deep cleaning and performing any necessary repairs to ensure the unit is in top condition. A well-presented property attracts prospective tenants quickly, reducing the time it remains vacant.

Use this opportunity to make upgrades that can enhance the property’s appeal, such as installing smart thermostats or updating appliances. These improvements help attract new tenants and can also justify higher rent prices.

Get a software demo

Multifamily software used by the top ten NMHC managers

Take full control of the lead-to-lease process

Get a demo